Comments on: Setting limits. http://larryborsato.com/blog/2006/03/setting-limits/ Unpredictable. Unfocused. Just like life. Tue, 08 Jun 2010 20:40:50 -0400 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.1 hourly 1 By: Alan http://larryborsato.com/blog/2006/03/setting-limits/comment-page-1/#comment-410 Alan Sat, 01 Apr 2006 04:37:38 +0000 http://alchemii.net/blog/2006/03/setting-limits/#comment-410 I agree with you that people need more common sense; certainly the ones with automatic-litigation-response reflexes do. So I won't defend their behavior. However, on an iPod, I can see why an volume limit setting would be a good idea. I certainly have a very eclectic collection of music. And when the iPod is on shuffle mode, I could easily go from a quiet Debussy piano piece, which I might have to increase the volume on while I'm on the train, to a screaming Nine Inch Nails track, which would have to be turned down. Even if I resort to ripping the headphone buds out of my ear (that hurts, BTW), there's still a second or two where my eardrums have been punished. I do NOT want volume compression (also known as Automatic Volume Leveling) because it tends to ruin the finer points of good music, and because it also takes a half-second or two to kick in. So I thing the Volume Limit is a good idea. Or think of it this way. Whether Apple adds that feature or not, the automatic-litigation-responders aren't going away. And you don't have to turn it on if you don't want it. And I don't see it dramatically affecting the price of an iPod anyway. There's my $1/50, ->A I agree with you that people need more common sense; certainly the ones with automatic-litigation-response reflexes do. So I won’t defend their behavior.

However, on an iPod, I can see why an volume limit setting would be a good idea. I certainly have a very eclectic collection of music. And when the iPod is on shuffle mode, I could easily go from a quiet Debussy piano piece, which I might have to increase the volume on while I’m on the train, to a screaming Nine Inch Nails track, which would have to be turned down. Even if I resort to ripping the headphone buds out of my ear (that hurts, BTW), there’s still a second or two where my eardrums have been punished.

I do NOT want volume compression (also known as Automatic Volume Leveling) because it tends to ruin the finer points of good music, and because it also takes a half-second or two to kick in. So I thing the Volume Limit is a good idea.

Or think of it this way. Whether Apple adds that feature or not, the automatic-litigation-responders aren’t going away. And you don’t have to turn it on if you don’t want it. And I don’t see it dramatically affecting the price of an iPod anyway.

There’s my $1/50,
->A

]]>