« Is AT&T a patent troll? | Main | Chat 2.0 »

Doing something.

Lots of folks like Nick Carr, Paul Kedrosky, and Mathew Ingram are taking Robert Scoble to task for a comment he made. Robert is upset that Google is getting loads of press and blog love for something that he feels Microsoft did months ago, but didn't get the equivalent credit for.

Some time ago Microsoft introduced the Live.com beta project. I recall they got a fair amount of press at the time, but there never seemed to be a clear direction. It just seemed to be a collection of "all this stuff we could do". It seemed like a solution in search of a problem. And months later, the situation really hasn't changed.

On the other hand, when Google announces something it seems that they've thought it out, and it does one thing well (generally) and one thing only. And it is already working, as in the case of the San Jose Community College email system. They have solved a problem.

Microsoft is getting an inordinate amount of press everyday for Vista, a new operating system, even though nobody can articulate a clear reason why I might need it, other than all the cool new features it will have. There isn't even a delivery date, but in Europe Microsoft is having a contest to see who can guess the release date.

Microsoft gets plenty of press for merely announcing something. I think it is perfectly reasonable for Google to get press for doing something.

Technorati:

Powered by Bleezer

Comments

Talking about addressing Robert's point...the issue wasn't about which company gets more press?!
In this particular case MSN came up with something long before Google, but the blogosphere (like in the Google Pack case) pretty much drooled over the Google announcement only. It seems that the "cheering for the underdog" (even though the underdog in this case is rather big I would say) is quite prevalent in these quarters...

And, BTW, it's not that ..."he feels Microsoft did months ago", MS actually did it.

Posted by: Pete Edberg on February 12, 2006 02:57 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?






Blogmap

Blogroll

Filangy WebMarks